27
July
2011

Travels with my friends. A booklover's trip to Europe. Part 2.

My thoughts on Garner's The Spare Room and Franzen's Freedom

Last time I wrote about the books I took to Italy: Jasper Jones and In Office Hours. But the story doesn’t end there.  So to continue...

Once in the UK I visited one of the ubiquitous Waterstone’s stores—the chain appears to have taken over bookselling in Britain—for more supplies, but didn’t make it past the recommended best sellers at the front door.  I was gratified to see The Slap amongst them, as well as Helen Garner’s most recent novel The Spare Room.  I’d been meaning to read the latter since it was published in 2008, after a good friend’s family was seduced into the sinister world of alternative cancer treatments (with the expected outcomes).

I was delighted to see the British reviews for The Spare Room were glowing; it was selected as a Book of the Year by no less than nine national newspapers. The English generally hand out praise grudgingly to Australians, especially when it comes to the Arts—it doesn’t fit their comfortable stereotype of Australia being the ‘dumb blonde’ of the world. But I guess talent will always win out in the end.

With The Spare Room Garner somehow manages to write an unsentimental book about a woman dying of cancer, yet still make it uplifting. That's why she's one of our most admired writers, I suppose. The only downside with the novel is that is so short —it certainly wasn’t going to support the long haul fight back to Oz. I compensated by including as my second purchase a great doorstopper of a book Freedom, by Jonathan Franzen.

I adored Franzen’s earlier novel, The Corrections, and was gripped by a fully fledged literary crush. I’d therefore been ready rush out and buy Freedom when it was published last year, until I started reading more and more about Franzen’s deification (the only writer to grace the cover of Time in a decade etc.etc.). The point was made that many writers of comparable talent—specifically women writers—rarely receive a fraction of the attention or accolades afforded this American white male.

I then stumbled across an article in Australian Author magazine that described Franzen as ‘notoriously difficult’.  How could the author of the warm and witty The Corrections possibly be difficult? It didn’t make sense to me. However, I  have since watched and read a few interviews with him and I can see he does have a prickly side—not one to suffer fools I’d suggest.

Still, when I saw Freedom in the bookshop in England, I knew it was time to relent (for a start the book was much cheaper than in Oz).  After all, if I’m not put off books with unlikeable characters it seemed unbearably precious to reject a novel because its author could be a touch curmudgeonly.

And my assessment?   Freedom is the best book I have read since I don’t know when, maybe since The Corrections.  Mr Franzen can be as ‘difficult’ as he likes; if he keeps writing books like Freedom I will continue to adore him. Of course, the debate will rage on whether Freedom is as good as many critics claim. But Franzen writes the sort of books I want to read—ones that examine big issues through the lives of a few exquisitely flawed individuals—and he does it better than any other writer I’ve ever come across.

I’m feeling quite bereft now that I finished Freedom. I find I’m not quite ready to leave the Berglunds behind.  In deference to Freedom’s brilliance I’ve have decided not read any fiction for a few weeks, instead I’m tackling a non-fiction work about autism which has been staring at me accusingly from my bedside table for several months.

Jasper Jones, The Spare Room and Freedom will somehow have to find a place in my bookcase, which is already far too crowded.  After all, we can never have too many friends.

What’s the best book you’ve read lately?

PS. The launch of the Australian Autism Handbook was held at Sydney’s wonderful Gleebooks in May 2008. The launch took place immediately after an author event with Helen Garner, who was promoting The Spare Room at the time.  I signed the authors’ book just below her. Can’t tell you how happy I was about that!

Comments (5)

  • 28 July 2011 at 20:09 |

    Glad to hear Freedom is worth it. I crossed it off my last book order at the last minute. Mistake! Will remedy asap.

    xo

  • 29 July 2011 at 19:38 |

    So glad to hear that you're not going to read me straight after Freedom!

    SO agree with this comment: "Franzen writes the sort of books I want to read—ones that examine big issues through the lives of a few exquisitely flawed individuals" Absolutely. I wouldn't rate Freedom as one of my best books of all time, but in the 5 days I was reading it I was totally engrossed, by both the characters and the plot. Books about how people really are- can't get enough of them. They're the ones I want to write, too. The Spare Room definitely falls into that category as well... needless to say, I really enjoyed this blog!

    • Benison OReilly
      29 July 2011 at 20:05 |

      I suspect I rate Franzen higher than you because you are much better read than me, Kylie. Unless you count autism books, that is.
      I read a review that described him as a modern day Thackeray or Dickens and that probably explains his appeal to me.
      Very much looking forward to reading Last Summer. I'm sure it will stack up well!

  • 30 July 2011 at 23:00 |

    I posted a comment here the other day, and it never showed up. I'll try again. I recently read The Gold Coast which is about what remains of the northern coast of Long Island, where at the turn of the century they built 50-room mansions and now no one can afford to live in them. I was hooked throughout the book, very well-written. And earlier this year, I read The Man in the Woods by Scott Spencer, who may be my favorite author of all time. He is one girfted writer. I liked your term "litery crush" and mine is on Scott Spencer. I read in a writing how-to book that his book Endless Love contained a 22-page sex scene and I was struggling over how to write them at the tme. (They made a movie of this book but it's cheesy and nothing like the book.) I didn't like that sex scene so much but loved the book so I read several others of his. I like to space them out. I did a book review on A Man in the Woods and in the first post I included a link to that. Maybe that's why the comment disappeared?

    • Benison O'Reilly (@BenisonAnne)
      31 July 2011 at 08:18 |

      No, sadly your previous post was lost. Sorry about that, Lynn. Will definitely check out the link to 'A Man in the Woods'. There are so many talented writers I have yet to discover. Another to add to the list!

Leave a comment

You are commenting as guest.

Cancel Submitting comment...